He is also shown to be disrespectful towards his own fans and police officers to the point that he engaged in a shootout with the police when they came to arrest him at Paradise Mall. In Postal 2, Gary is presented unpleasantly, uses vulgar words, and is annoyed by the continued sale of his signed books on Ebay, going as far as to use verbal threats to prevent such. However, in Postal 2: Apocalypse Weekend is heavily battered, wrapped up in bandages in many places, with a black eye and a patch on his head. Gary, like in the real world, is a low Afro-American, in Postal 2 he wears a white suit, trousers and a tie, and a blue shirt. In turn, in Paradise Lost, Gary appears for the first time on Thursday as the leader of the Dwarves. However, in Apocalypse Weekend, you can find him at the hospital on Saturday.

In Postal 2, Gary can be found on Tuesday at Paradise Mall, where he gives his autobiograph autographed, and on Friday, you can see him locked in a cell at the Police Station in the company of Krotchy.